Medicare Supplement Plans in Colorado

There are a variety of Medicare supplemental providers and plans. These providers specialize in Medigap coverages and are often fighting for new consumers. Be sure to compare multiple quotes so that you can have some leverage when discussing a new policy with potential insurers. The most recognizable names in the Colorado Medicare Supplement coverage market include Aetna Health, Anthem/Blue Cross, Coventry Health, Regence/Blue Shield and United Health Care. But these giants aren’t alone—there are dozens of smaller insurance companies selling Medicare Supplement and Medicare Part C/Advantage plans here.
 
 

Here is a list of Medicare supplement plans available in the state of Colorado. This data was accurate at the time of publishing…
 
 

Features
Sex
A
B
C
D
F
Fhi
G
K
L
M
N

Aetna Life Insurance Company | 1-800-345-6022

AA, GEO, GIL(6), TBU
Female
121.49
134.46

152.07

125.89

98.68

Male
131.59
146.47

165.38

133.74

104.69

American Continental Insurance Company | 1‐800‐264‐4000

AA, AC, GEO, PF($20), TBU
Female
83.88
105.75

122.80
48.37
107.58

85.37

Male
94.67
121.58

141.26
55.54
123.68

88.22

American Republic Corp Insurance Company | 1‐888‐755‐3065

AA, AC, GEO, HD, TBU
Female
118.00

160.00
62.00

83.00
114.00

Male
131.00

178.00
75.00

92.00
127.00

Bankers Fidelity Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐241‐1439

AA, AC, GEO, HD, TBU
Female
117.00

162.00
57.00

81.00

Male
117.00

162.00
57.00

81.00

Central States Indemnity Co. of Omaha | 1‐866‐644‐3988

AA, AC, GEO, PF($25), TBU
Female
96.17
112.25
134.50

139.75

97.83

Male
110.50
129.08
154.67

160.67

112.50

Colonial Penn Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐800‐2254

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
103.82
132.31

151.07
37.02
134.89
57.39
94.39
115.26
84.54

Male
115.24
146.90

167.75
41.02
149.77
63.65
104.77
127.95
93.82

Combined Insurance Company of America | 1‐800‐544‐5531

AA, AC, TBU
Female
103.42

147.75

103.42

Male
103.42

147.75

103.42

Constitution Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐444‐0321

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(6), PF($25), TBU
Female
93.00

104.00
122.00

110.00

83.00

Male
107.00

120.00
141.00

127.00

95.00

Continental General Insurance Company | 1‐866‐459‐4272

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(6), PF($25), TBU
Female
114.02

140.27

122.00

114.00

Male
123.10

151.56

131.46

122.64

Equitable Life & Casualty | 1‐877‐358‐4060

AA, GEO, PF($20), TBU
Female
106.00

150.09

105.59

Male
121.84

172.59

121.59

Everence Association, Inc., a fraternal benefit society | 1‐800‐348‐7468

AC, FBP, GEO, IA
Female
116.91

195.40

112.02

Male
128.60

214.95

123.24

Family Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐877‐7703

AA, AC, GEO, HD,PF($25), TBU
Female
102.00
124.00
142.42
130.17
148.33

130.83

117.17
103.92

Male
117.42
142.67
163.83
149.67
170.58

150.33

134.75
119.33

Gerber Life Insurance Company | 1‐877‐778‐0839

AA, AC, GEO, PF($25), TBU
Female
101.92

145.12

123.07

Male
117.15

166.81

141.46

Globe Life and Accident Insurance Company | 1‐800‐801‐6831

AA, AC, GIL(2)
Female
88.50
127.50
144.00

145.50

Male
88.50
127.50
144.00

145.50

Government Personnel Mutual Life Insurance Company | 1‐866‐865‐7631

AA, AC, GEO, PF($25), TBU
Female
112.37

149.38

152.99

118.88

104.87

Male
129.16

171.71

175.85

136.64

120.53

Guarantee Trust Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐338‐7452

AA, AC, GEO, HD, PF($25), TBU
Female
91.62

131.88

90.99

Male
105.25

151.48

104.62

Heartland National Life Insurance Company | 1‐877‐431‐7371

AA, AC, GEO, PF($25), TBU
Female
92.58

116.50
134.91

118.33

108.91
93.83

Male
106.41

133.91
154.99

136.16

125.24
107.91

Humana Insurance Company | 1‐888‐310‐8482

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(6), TBU
Female
130.10
141.59
163.25

166.58
62.47

76.30
108.44

Male
130.43
141.96
163.67

167.00
62.63

76.49
108.72

Liberty National Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐331‐2512

AA, Select policies AC, GIL(2), TBU
Female
111.00
154.00

175.00
40.00

138.00

Male
127.00
177.00

201.00
46.00

158.00

Loyal American Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐633‐6752

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(6), PF($25), TBU
Female
135.09

166.03

144.89

134.52

Male
145.85

179.36

156.41

145.28

Medico Insurance Company | 1‐800‐228‐6080

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
98.19

138.78

125.70

114.59

115.87
109.65

Male
109.43

151.41

144.67

126.00

127.34
121.98

Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company | 1‐800-667-2937

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
115.84

168.66
147.04
172.98

154.30

Male
133.15

193.87
169.01
198.83

177.36

Physicians Mutual | 1‐800‐228‐9100

Range of AA & IA, AC, GEO, HD, TBU
Female
118 ‐ 141

141 ‐ 243
63 ‐ 86
154 ‐ 186

122 ‐ 163

Male
118 ‐ 141

141 ‐ 243
63 ‐ 86
154 ‐ 186

122 ‐ 163

Reserve National Insurance Company | 1‐800‐654‐9106

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(6), PF($15), TBU
Female
106.05

169.30

137.50
43.20
120.00

108.65

Male
106.05

169.30

137.50
43.20
138.00

108.65

Rocky Mountain HealthCare Options, Inc. | 1‐888‐282‐1420

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(0-6), TBU
Female
101.30

148.05

155.84

163.64

104.42

Male
117.11

171.16

180.17

189.18

120.71

Rocky Mountain Hospital & Medical Service, Inc. | 1‐877‐831‐3000 (aka Anthem Blue Cross/Blue Shield)

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(6), HD
Female
101.62

145.18
49.56
135.74

100.17

Male
117.78

168.26
55.72
157.32

116.10

Royal Neighbors of America | 1‐800‐568‐2382

AA, AC, GEO, PF($20), TBU
Female
104.88
131.78
153.61
123.03
154.11

123.45

Male
117.45
147.52
172.01
137.78
172.51

138.36

Sentinel Security Life Insurance Company | 1‐855‐478‐4037

AA, AC, GEO, PF($25), TBU
Female
89.91
99.68
122.16
107.82
125.11

92.69

Male
103.34
114.57
140.41
123.93
143.80

106.54

Standard Life & Accident Insurance Company | 1‐888‐350‐1488

AA, GEO, TBU
Female
223.93
273.07
310.46
187.07
255.31
34.70
188.50

123.13

Male
239.83
273.07
310.46
187.07
255.31
34.70
188.50

123.13

State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | Contact Local State Farm Agent

AA, AC, GEO
Female
97.15

146.54

147.98

Male
97.15

146.54

147.98

State Mutual Insurance Company | 1‐888‐764‐1936

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
107.33
125.33
150.08
131.33
155.92
61.42
132.08

118.08
109.00

Male
123.50
144.08
172.67
151.00
179.42
70.58
151.92

136.00
125.58

Sterling Investors Life Insurance Company | 1‐877‐896‐6434

AA, AC, GEO, PF($20), TBU
Female
127.08
148.50
177.67
155.50
184.58
72.67
156.42

139.92
129.25

Male
146.17
170.58
204.42
178.92
212.50
83.58
179.83

161.00
148.75

Sterling Life Insurance Company | 1‐877‐906‐0926

AA, AC, GEO, GIL(Check w/company), TBU
Female
161.56
185.56
191.14

183.25

81.64

140.08

Male
161.56
185.56
207.07

198.52

88.44

151.75

The Order of United Commercial Travelers of America | 1‐800‐848‐0123

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
87.89
113.46
135.98
124.45
139.75

122.98

97.82

Male
101.08
130.47
156.38
143.12
160.71

141.43

112.50

Thrivent Financial for Lutherans | 1‐800‐847‐4836

AA or IA; AA rates shown, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
100.80
119.16
154.38
132.64
154.90
50.68
136.54

95.28
120.62

Male
100.80
119.16
154.38
132.64
154.90
50.68
136.54

95.28
120.62

United American Insurance Company | 1‐800‐331‐2512

AA, Select policies AC, GIL(2), TBU
Female
100.00
145.00
165.00
152.00
166.00
38.00
153.00
84.00
119.00

130.00

Male
115.00
167.00
189.00
175.00
191.00
43.00
176.00
96.00
137.00

150.00

United World Life Insurance Company | 1‐800-667-2937

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
152.73
136.69
187.78
148.72
188.24

188.94

135.34

Male
175.55
175.11
215.83
170.95
216.37

217.18

155.67

UnitedHealthcare Insurance Company | 1‐800‐768‐1479

AA, AC, GEO, TBU
Female
111.06

149.38
48.11
134.61
70.78
97.26

100.11

Male
111.06

149.38
48.11
134.61
70.78
97.26

100.11

USAA Life Insurance Company | 1‐800‐531‐8722

AA, AC, GIL(Must pass underwriting), TBU
Female
75.31

141.78

Male
75.31

141.78

Woodmen of the World | 1‐877‐223‐3666

AA, AC, GEO, PF($25), TBU
Female
105.68
120.04
140.87
111.63
144.28

112.13

99.01

Male
121.47
137.98
161.92
128.32
165.84

128.89

113.81

World Corp Insurance Company | 1‐800‐822‐9993

AA, AC, GEO, HD, TBU
Female
112.00

148.00
58.00

Male
124.00

165.00
64.00